Uncontested vs Contested Divorce in NJ

When facing divorce in New Jersey, one of your first critical decisions determines everything that follows: will your divorce be uncontested or contested? This choice affects your timeline, costs, and emotional well-being throughout the process. Understanding the difference between a New Jersey uncontested divorce and a contested divorce helps you navigate this difficult time with greater confidence, and learning how to save money on divorce can make a significant difference in your financial outcome.

Understanding the Two Paths

An uncontested divorce in New Jersey occurs when you and your spouse agree on all major issues—property division, spousal support, child custody, parenting time, and child support. You present the Superior Court with a complete Marital Settlement Agreement, and in many cases, you can finalize everything through "divorce on the papers" without ever appearing in court.

A contested divorce means you and your spouse disagree on one or more significant issues. These disputes require the court's intervention through discovery, mandatory mediation, motion practice, and potentially a trial where a judge makes final decisions about your finances and children.

New Jersey uses "irreconcilable differences" as its primary no-fault divorce ground. You must show that irreconcilable differences have existed for at least six months and caused a breakdown with no reasonable prospect of reconciliation. Unlike some states, New Jersey doesn't require physical separation—the six-month period can occur while you're still living together.

All divorces are filed in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Chancery Division, Family Part, in the county where you lived when you separated.

Cost Comparison: What You'll Actually Pay

The financial difference between uncontested and contested divorces in New Jersey can be substantial.

Uncontested Divorce Costs in New Jersey

• Court filing fee: $300
• Response filing (if needed): $175
• Parent education program: $25 per parent (when custody is at issue)
• Attorney fees (optional): $2,000-$7,000 for straightforward cases
• Total typical range: $500-$7,000

Many couples complete uncontested divorces for under $1,000 if they handle paperwork themselves, though most benefit from at least limited attorney guidance to ensure their Marital Settlement Agreement protects their interests.

Contested Divorce Costs in New Jersey

• All the same filing fees as above
• Attorney retainer: $2,500-$7,500 to start
• Ongoing attorney fees: $150-$350 per hour
• Discovery costs: $3,000-$10,000
• Expert witnesses: $2,000-$10,000+ (custody evaluators, forensic accountants, appraisers)
• Mediation (mandatory in NJ): $1,500-$5,000
• Trial preparation and attendance: $5,000-$15,000
• Total typical range: $15,000-$20,000+

High-conflict divorces involving substantial assets or intensive custody disputes can exceed $30,000-$50,000. Each motion filed, each court appearance, and each round of discovery adds to your total, making contested divorces financially draining for most New Jersey families. For a detailed comparison of litigation versus alternative dispute resolution costs, see our guide on divorce battle or mediation cost.

Timeline Comparison: How Long Will This Take?

Uncontested Divorce Timeline in New Jersey

• Residency requirement: 1 year in New Jersey before filing
• "Irreconcilable differences" period: 6 months minimum
• Processing after filing: 2-6 months
• Typical total duration: 3-8 months

New Jersey allows "divorce on the papers" under Directive #01-25, meaning if you meet certain requirements, you can finalize your uncontested divorce without any court appearance. You simply submit your Marital Settlement Agreement and supporting documents, and the court reviews and approves everything in writing.

Contested Divorce Timeline in New Jersey

• Same residency and grounds requirements
• Discovery phase: 90-120 days (depending on case track)
• Mandatory mediation: 1-3 months
• Motion practice: 2-4 months
• Trial scheduling and completion: 3-6+ months
• Typical total duration: 12-18 months or more

New Jersey's mandatory mediation requirement in contested cases adds time but often helps couples resolve disputes without trial. The court assigns cases to "tracks" (Expedited, Standard, or Complex) that determine discovery deadlines and case management schedules.

Making the Right Choice for Your Situation

The decision between uncontested and contested divorce isn't always entirely within your control—if your spouse refuses to negotiate reasonably or discloses financial information incompletely, you may have no choice but to litigate.

Uncontested divorce works best when:

• Both spouses can communicate respectfully
• You have complete financial transparency
• Property and debt division seems fair to both parties
• You can agree on a parenting plan that serves your children's needs
• No domestic violence or safety concerns exist
• Neither spouse is hiding assets or income

Contested divorce may be necessary when:

• Your spouse refuses to disclose financial information
• Significant assets require expert valuation
• One spouse has hidden or dissipated marital assets
• Serious disagreements exist about custody or parenting time
• Domestic violence or substance abuse affects parenting decisions
• Power imbalances make fair negotiation impossible

New Jersey requires mediation before contested divorces go to trial, giving couples one more opportunity to resolve disputes and save the time and expense of litigation. Many cases settle during or after mediation once both spouses understand the likely trial outcomes.

Your Next Steps

Whether your New Jersey divorce will be uncontested or contested, taking action now puts you in a stronger position. Start by organizing your financial documents: tax returns, bank statements, retirement account statements, mortgage documents, and records of debts.

Use our New Jersey Divorce Cost Calculator above to estimate what your divorce might cost based on whether it's uncontested or contested. This planning tool helps you prepare financially for the months ahead.

Consider consulting with a New Jersey family law attorney even if you expect an uncontested divorce. An attorney can review your Marital Settlement Agreement to ensure it complies with New Jersey law (N.J.S.A. 2A:34-2) and protects your interests. For contested divorces, legal representation is essential to navigate the Superior Court system and protect your rights.

The path you take through divorce—uncontested or contested—significantly shapes your experience and your future. By understanding the differences in cost, timeline, and process, you can make informed decisions that serve your long-term well-being.

Related Articles

Financial

Protecting Separate Property in New York

How to protect separate property in New York divorce: tracing strategies under DRL § 236(B), avoiding commingling, and meeting the burden of proof standard.

Read guideProtecting Separate Property in New York

Financial

Protecting Separate Property in Florida

How to protect non-marital property in Florida divorce: tracing strategies under Florida Statute 61.075, enhancement claims, and avoiding commingling pitfalls.

Read guideProtecting Separate Property in Florida